Slides from my Evaluation 2019 session and the Standards of Evidence Codebook.As part of the Knowledge Management and Dissemination for the MSPs project, HRI developed the original Standards of Evidence review (Heck & Minner, 2010) to evaluate studies and provide detailed feedback on reporting empirical research procedures and evidence to support claims. HRI continues to use the Standards of Evidence review to evaluate the credibility of study claims. The protocol HRI currently uses was revised in 2014 for the evaluation of NSF’s Research and Evaluation in Engineering and Science Education (REESE) program.